Biodentine TM or MTA ProRoot TM: the comparative analysis of application in endodontics

Relevance. Use of materials based on the calcium silicate (CSM) in dentistry became popular with the advent of the Mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) in 1993 as root filler. However in the market of dental services constantly new materials appear which are convenient in use, and also have the best properties, than predecessors. Recently BiodentineTM was provided as "the first universal, biologically active and biocompatible material for replacement of the damaged dentine". Producers claim that BiodentineTM has much shorter time of a curing unlike other silicate cements, such as (MTA) and also has the best mechanical and operational properties. This review of the literature is directed to comparative assessment of physical and chemical, biological ProRoot MTA TM and Biodentine TM properties.

1. Манак Т. Н., Клюйко К. Г., Митронин В. А. Обтурация корневых каналов как важнейший этап подготовки зуба к органосохраняющей операции // Эндодонтия Today. 2019. Т. 17. №1. С. 42-45. Manak T. N., Klyuko K. G., Mitronin V. A. Root canal obstruction as an important stage in tooth preparation for organ-preserving surgery // Endodontics Today. 2019. Vol. 17. №1. P. 42-45.

2. Берхман М. В., Козлова С. С., Просин А. И., Черненко О. В. Апикальная микрохирургия vs повторное ортоградное лечение корневых каналов: критерии выбора метода лечения. Часть 1 // Эндодонтия today. 2019. 17 (2). С. 59-64. Berkhman M. V., Kozlova S. S., Prosin A. I., Chernenko O. V. Apical microsurgery vs repeated orthograde treatment of root canals: criteria for selection of a method of treatment. Part 1 // Endodontics today. 2019. №17 (2). Р. 59-64.

3. Митронин А. В., Рабинович И. М., Корнетова И. В. Лечение пациента с хроническим апикальным периодонтитом зуба 2.1 при наличии перфорации корня зуба 2.2. Клинический случай // Эндодонтия Today. 2018. №2. С. 72-77. Mitronin A. V., Rabinovich I. M., Kornetova I. V. Treatment of a patient with chronic apical periodontitis of the tooth 2.1 in the presence of perforation of the tooth root 2.2. Clinical case // Endodontics Today. 2018. №2. P. 72-77.

4. Torabinejad M., Rastegar A. F., Kettering J. D., Pitt Ford, T.R. Bacterial leakage of the mineral trioxide aggregate as a root end filler // Journal of endodontics. 1995. №21 (3). Р. 109-112.

5. Torabinejad M., Hong K. W., Pitt Ford, TR R., Kettering, J. D. Cytotoxicity of the four root end fillers // Journal of endodontics. 1995. №21 (10). Р. 489-492.

6. Torabinejad M., Smith P. V., Kettering J. D., Pitt Ford T. R. Comparative study of the marginal adaptation of the mineral trioxide aggregate and other widely used root fillers // Journal of endodontics. 1995. №21 (6). Р. 295-299.

7. Main S., Mirzayan N., Shabahang S., Torabinejad M. Restoration of root perforations using a mineral trioxide aggregate: a long-term study // Journal of endodontics. 2004. №30 (2). Р. 80-83.

8. Thorabinejad M., Pitt Ford T. R. Root Fillers: Overview // Endod Dent Traumatol. 1996. №12. Р. 161-178.

9. Korbella S., Ferrara G., El Kabbaney A., Tashieri S. Apexification, apexogenez and regenerative endodontic procedures: a review of the literature // Minerva Dentistry. 2014. №63 (11-12). Р. 375-389.

10. Thorabinejad M., Hong Chu, Pitt Ford T. R., Kettering J. D. Antibacterial action of some root fillers // J Endod. 1995. №21. Р. 403-406.

11. Chung C.J., Kim E., Song M., Pak J.V., Shin S.J. The effect of two fast-setting calcium silicate cements on cell viability and the release of angiogenic factor in cells derived from human pulp // Odontology. 2016. №104 (2). Р. 143-151.

12. Ramos J. C., Palma P. J., Nascimento R. et al. 1-year in vitro assessment of teeth discoloration caused by 2 calcium silicate cements // Journal of endodontics. 2016. №42 (9). Р. 1403-1407.

13. Chianconi L., Palopoli P., Campanella V. et al. Composition and microstructure of MTA and Aureoseal Plus: XRF, EDS, XRD and FESEM // European Journal of Pediatric Dentistry. 2016. №17 (4). Р. 281-285.

14. On I. Biodentin: from biochemical and bioactive properties to clinical applications // Giornale Italiano di Endodonzia. 2016. №30 (2). Р. 81-88.

15. Gilles R., Olivier M., inventors. Septodont, applicant. Dental composition. Patent WO 2011/124841, US 2013/ 0025498. 2011.

16. Abdullah D., Ford T. R., Papaioannou S., Nicholson J. et al. An evaluation of accelerated Portland cement as a restorative material // Biomaterials. 2002. №23 (19). Р. 4001-4010.

17. Camilleri J., Pitt Ford T. R. Mineral trioxide aggregate: a re- view of the constituents and biological properties of the material // Int Endod J. 2006. №39. Р. 747-754.

18. Watts J. D., Holt D. M., Beeson T. J. et al. Effects of pH and mixing agents on the temporal setting of tooth-colored and gray mineral trioxide aggregate // J Endod. №33. Р. 970-973.

19. Torabinejad M., Hong Kong, MacDonald F, et al. Physical and chemical properties of the new root filling material // J Endod. 1995. №21. Р. 349-353.

20. Danesh G., Dammashke T., Gert Hu. V. et al. Comparative study of i ndividual p roperties o f t he P roRoot M TA a nd tw o P ortland c ements // Int Endod J. 2006. №39. Р. 213-219.

21. Poggio S., Lombardini M., Alessandro S., Simonetta R. Solubility of root fillers: a comparative study // J Endod. 2007. №33. Р. 1094-1097.

22. Tay F. R., Pashley D. H., Rueggeberg F. A. et al. Calcium phosphate phase transformation produced by the interaction of the portland cement component of white mineral trioxide aggregate with a phosphate-containing fluid // Journal of Endodontics. 2007. №33. Р. 1347-1351.

23. Han L., Okiji T., Okawa S. Morphological and chemical analysis of different precipitates on mineral trioxide aggregate immersed in different fluids // Dental Materials Journal. 2010. №29. Р. 512-517.

24. Sarkar N., Caicedo R., Ritwik P. et al. Physicochemical basis of the biologic properties of mineral trioxide aggregate // Journal of Endodontics. 2005. №31. Р. 97-100.

25. Atmeh A. R., Chong E. Z., Richard G. et al. Dentin–cement interfacial interaction: calcium silicates and polyalkenoates // Journal of Dental Research. 2012. №91. Р. 454-459.

26. Jong Ryul Kim, Ali Nosrat, Ashraf F. Fouad. Interfacial characteristics of Biodentine and MTA with dentine in simulated body fluid. Journal of Dentistry. Volume 43, Issue 2, February 2015, Pages 241-247.

27. Danesh G., Dammashke T., Gert Hu. V., Zandbiglari T., Shefer E. Comparative study of individual properties of the ProRoot MTA and two Portland cements // Int Endod J. 2006. №39. Р. 213-219.

28. Nekofofar M. Kh., Adusey G., Sheikhrezaye M. S., Hayes S. J., Bryant S. T., Dummer P. M. H. Effect of condensation pressure on the individual physical properties of a mineral trioxide aggregate // Int Endod J. 2007. №40. Р. 453-461.

29. Ryge G., Foley D. E., Fairhurst C. W. Microindentation hardness // J Dent Res. 1961. №40. Р. 1116-1126.

30. Gandolfi M. G., Iacono F., Agee K., Siboni F., Tay F., Pashley D. H. et al. The setting time and expansion in various media are experimental experimental accelerated calcium silicate cements and the ProRoot MTA // Oral Surg Oral Med Oral patol Oral radiol Endod. 2009. 108: e39-45.

31. Laghios C. D., Benson B. W., Gutmann J. L., Cutler C. W. Comparative X-ray contrast of tetracalcium phosphate and other root fillers // Int Endod J. 2000. №33. Р. 311-315.

32. Grech L., Mallia B., Camilleri J. Study of the physical properties of root-based fillers based on tricalcium silicate cement // Dent Mater. 2013. 29: e20-8.

33. Pariroh M., Torabinejad M. The mineral trioxide aggregate: a complete review of the literature, part I: Chemical, physical and antibacterial properties // J Endod. 2010. №36. Р. 16-27.

34. Zhou H. M., Shen Y., Wang Z. J., Li L., Zheng Y. F., Häkkinen L. et al. Evaluation of in vitro cytotoxicity of root recovery material // J Endod. 2013. №39. Р. 478-483.

35. Al-Hezaymi K., Al-Shalan TA, Naggsbandi J., Oglesby S., Simon J. H., Rotshtein I. Antibacterial effect of preparations of two mineral trioxide aggregates (MTA) against Enterococcus faecalis and Streptococcus sanguis in vitro // J Endod. 2006. №32. Р. 1053-1056.

36. Ceci M., Beltrami R., Chiesa M., Colombo M., Poggio C. Biological and chemical-physical properties of root-end filling materials: A comparative study. J Conserv Dent. 2015;18(2):94–99.

37. Laurent P., Camps J., About I. Biodentine(TM) induces TGFbeta1 release from human pulp cells and early dental pulp mineralization // Int Endod J. 2012. №45. Р. 439-448.

38. Nikoludaki G. E., Kontogiannis T., Meliu N. A., Kerezudis N. P. A comparative in vitro study of the sealing ability of four different materials used in furcation perforation // Open J Stomatol. 2014. №4. Р. 402-411.

39. Soundappan S., Sundaramurthy J. L., Raghu S., Natanasabapathy V. Biodentine in comparison with the mineral trioksid unit in comparison with the intermediate restoring material for retrograde sealing of the root ends: research in vitro // J Dent (Tehran). 2014. №11. Р. 143-149.

40. Handelvall A., Karthik J., Nadig R. R., Jain A. The sealing ability of the mineral trioxide aggregate and biodentin as a material for filling root ends using two different methods of retro-preparation – an in vitro study // Int J Contemp Dent Med Rev. 2015. №150. Р. 115-121.

41. Seok Wu Chang., Kartik J., Nadig R. R., Jain A. Chemical composition and characteristics of the porosity of various endodontic cements based on calcium silicate // Int J Contemp Dent Med Rev. 2015. №150. Р. 115-121.

42. Valles M., Roig M., Duran-Sindreu F. et al. Color stability of teeth restored with Biodentine: a 6-month in vitro study // J Endod. 2015. №41. Р. 1157-1160.

43. Kang S. H., Shin Y. S., Lee H. S. et al. Color changes of teeth after treatment with various mineral trioxide aggregate-based materials: an ex vivo study // J Endod. 2015. №41. Р. 737-734.

44. Schwendicke F. Allam Al-Abdi, Agustín Pascual Moscardó, Alvaro Ferrando Cascales, Salvatore Sauroc. Remineralization effects of conventional and experimental ion-releasing materials in chemically or bacterially-induced dentin caries lesions // J Dent Res. 2013. №92 (4). Р. 306-314.

45. Nagas E., Cehreli Z. C., Uyanik M. O., Vallittu P. K., Lassila L. V. J. Effect of several intracanal medicaments on the push-out bond strength of ProRoot MTA and Biodentine // International Endodontic Journal. 2015. №49 (2). Р. 184-188.

46. Guneser M. B., Akbulut M. B., Eldeniz A. U. Effect of various endodontic irrigants on the push-out bond strength of biodentine and conventional root perforation repair materials // Journal of Endodontics. 2013. №39. Р. 380-384.

47. Han L., Okiji T. Uptake of calcium and silicon released from calcium silicate-based endodontic materials into root canal dentine // International Endodontic Journal. 2011. №44. Р. 1081-1087.

48. Atmeh A. R., Chong E. Z., Richard G., Festy F., Watson T. F. Dentin-cement interfacial interaction: calcium silicates and polyalkenoates // Journal of Dental Research. 2012. №91. Р. 454-459.

49. Felman D., Parashos P. Coronal tooth discoloration and white mineral trioxide aggregate // J Endod. 2013. №39. Р. 484-487.

50. Valles M., Mercade M., Duran-Sindreu F. et al. Influence of light and oxygen on the color stability of five calcium silicate-based materials // J Endod. 2013. №39. Р. 525-528.

51. Camilleri J. Color stability of white mineral trioxide aggregate in contact with hypochlorite solution // J Endod. 2014. №40. Р. 436-440.

52. Marconyak L. J., Kirkpatrick T. C., Roberts H. W., Roberts M. D., Aparicio A., Himel V. T., Sabey K. A. A Comparison of Coronal Tooth Discoloration Elicited by Various Endodontic Reparative Materials // Journal of Endodontics. 2016. №42 (3). Р. 470-473.

53. Marciano M. A., Costa R. M., Camilleri J. et al. Assessment of color stability of white mineral trioxide aggregate angelus and bismuth oxide in contact with tooth structure // J Endod. 2014. №40. Р. 1235-

54.

55. Kang S., Shin Y., Lee H. et al. Color changes of teeth after treatment with various mineral trioxide aggregate-based materials: an ex vivo study // J Endod. 2015. №41. Р. 737-741.

56. Chang S.-W., Lee S.-Y., Ann H.-J., Kum, K.-Y., Kim E.-C. The effect of endodontic cements on calcium silicate on biocompatibility and mineralizing potentials in human tooth pulp cells // Journal of Endodontics. 2014. №40 (8). Р. 1194-1200.

57. Ozdemir H. O., Ozcelik B., Karabucak B. et al. Calcium ion diffusion from mineral trioxide aggregate through simulated root resorption defects // Dent Traumatol. 2008. №24. Р. 70-73.

58. Zhou H. M., Shen Y., Wang Z. J. et al. In vitro cytotoxicity evaluation of a novel root repair material // J Endod. 2013. №39. Р. 478- 483.

59. Hirschman W. R., Wheater M. A., Bringas J. S., Hoen M. M. Cytotoxicity comparison of three current direct pulp-capping agents with a new bioceramic root repair putty // J Endod. 2012. №38 (3). Р. 385-388.

60. Nowicka A., Lipski M., Parafiniuk M., Sporniak-Tutak K., Lichota D., Kosierkiewicz A., Buczkowska-Radlińska J. Response of Human Dental Pulp Capped with Biodentine and Mineral Trioxide Aggregate // Journal of Endodontics. 2013. №39 (6). Р. 743-747.

61. Camilleri J., Montesin F., Brady K., Sweeney R., Curtis R., Ford T. The constitution of mineral trioxide aggregate // Dental Materials. 2005. №21 (4). Р. 297-303.

62. Asgary S., Eghbal M. J., Parirokh M. et al. A comparative study of histologic response to different pulp capping materials and a novel endodontic cement // Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2008. №106. Р. 609-614.

63. Zarrabi M H., Javidi M., Jafarian A. H., Joushan B. Histologic assessment of human pulp response to capping with mineral trioxide aggregate and a novel endodontic cement // J Endod. 2010. №36. Р. 1778-1781.

64. Al-Hezaimi K., Salameh Z., Al-Fouzan K. et al. Histomorphometric and microcomputed tomography analysis of pulpal response to three different pulp capping materials // J Endod. 2011. №37. Р. 507-512.

65. Laurent P., Camps J., About I. BiodentineTM induces TGF-b1 release from human pulp cells and early dental pulp mineralization // Int Endod J. 2012. №45. Р. 439-448.

66. Zanini M., Sautier J. M., Berdal A., Simon S. Biodentine induces immortalized murine pulp cell differentiation into odontoblast-like cells and stimulates biomineralization // J Endod. 2012. №38. 1220-1226.

67. Koubi G., Colon P., Franquin J. C. et al. Clinical evaluation of the performance and safety of a new dentine substitute, Biodentine, in the restoration of posterior teeth: a prospective study // Clin Oral Investig. 2013. №17. Р. 243-249.

68. Raskin A., Eschrich G., Dejou J., About I. In vitro microleakage of Biodentine as a dentin substitute compared to Fuji II LC in cervical lining restorations // J Adhes Dent. 2012. №14. Р. 535-542.

69. Koubi S., Elmerini H., Koubi G. et al. Quantitative evaluation by glucose diffusion of microleakage in aged calcium silicate-based opensandwich restorations // Int J Dent. 2012. 2012:105863.

70. Laurent P., Camps J., De Meo M. et al. Induction of specific cell responses to a Ca3SiO- based posterior restorative material // Dent Mater. 2008. №24. Р. 1486-1494.

71. Tran X. V., Gorin C., Willig C. et al. Effect of a calcium-silicatebased restorative cement on pulp repair // J Dent Res. 2012. №91. Р. 1166-1171.

72. Iwamoto C. E., Adachi E., Pameijer C. H. et al. Clinical and histological evaluation of white ProRoot MTA in direct pulp capping // Am J Dent. 2006. №19. Р. 85-90.

73. Aeinehchi M., Eslami B., Ghanbariha M., Saffar A. S. Mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) and calcium hydroxide as pulp-capping agents in human teeth: a preliminary report // Int Endod J. 2003. №36. Р. 225-231.

74. Eskandarizadeh A., Shahpasandzadeh M. H., Shahpasandzadeh M. et al. A comparative study on dental pulp response to calcium hydroxide, white and grey mineral trioxide aggregate as pulp capping agents // J Conserv Dent. 2011. №14. Р. 351-355.

75. Faraco I. M. Jr, Holland R. Response of the pulp of dogs to capping with mineral trioxide aggregate or a calcium hydroxide cement // Dent Traumatol. 2001. №17. Р. 163-166.

76. Accorinte M. L., Loguercio A. D., Reis A. et al. Response of human dental pulp capped with MTA and calcium hydroxide powder // Oper Dent. 2008. №33. Р. 488-495.

77. Wattanapakkavong K., Srisuwan T., Clin Dent G. D. Release of Transforming Growth Factor Beta 1 from Human Tooth Dentin After Application of Either ProRoot MTA or Biodentine as a Coronal Barrier // Journal of Endodontics. 2019.

78. Graham L., Cooper P. R., Cassidy N. et al. The effect of calcium hydroxide on solubilisation of bio-active dentine matrix components // Biomaterials. 2006. №27. Р. 2865-2873.

79. Zeid S. A., Alothmani O. S., Yousef M. K. Biodentine and mineral trioxide aggregate: an analysis of solubility, pH changes and leaching elements // Life Sci J. 2015. №12. Р. 18-23.

80. Miller A. A., Takimoto K., Wealleans J., Diogenes A. Effect of 3 bioceramic materials on stem cells of the apical papilla proliferation and differentiation using a dentin disk model // J Endod. 2018. №44. Р. 599-603.

81. Wongwatanasanti N., Jantarat J., Sritanaudomchai H., Hargreaves K. M. Effect of bioceramic materials on proliferation and odontoblast differentiation of human stem cells from the apical papilla // J Endod. 2018. №44 (8). Р. 1270-1275.

82. Smith A. J., Scheven B. A., Takahashi Y. et al. Dentine as a bioactive extracellular matrix. Arch Oral Biol. 2012. №57. Р. 109-121.

83. Tomson P. L., Grover L. M., Lumley P. J. et al. Dissolution of bioactive dentine matrix components by mineral trioxide aggregate // J Dent 2007. №35. Р. 636-642.

84. Han L, Okiji T. Bioactivity evaluation of three calcium silicatebased endodontic materials _ Int Endod J 2013. №46. Р. 808-814.

85. Gandolfi M. G., Siboni F., Botero T. et al. Calcium silicate and calcium hydroxide materials for pulp capping: biointeractivity, porosity, solubility and bioactivity of current formulations // J Appl Biomater Funct Mater. 2015. №13. Р. 43-60.