Comparative characteristic of the effectiveness of instrumental treatment of teeth with a C-shaped root canal
https://doi.org/10.33925/1683-2981-2019-17-1-27-31
Abstract
Aim. Compare the effectiveness of dental instrumentation with a C-shaped root canal system with two different endodontic systems: XP-endo and Gentlefile.
Materials and methods. The study was performed on 30 teeth removed by medical reasons (18 premolars and 12 second molars of the lower jaw). Samples were divided randomly into 2 equal groups. Separately, three C-shaped mandibular premolars were processed with XP-endo and Gentlefile systems and manual steel files for scanning electron microscopy. For comparison, one rough premolar was taken. The C-shaped configuration was confirmed by cone-beam computed tomography. The quality of endodontic treatment of root canals was assessed by the microstructure of the surface of the root dentin using a scanning electron microscope, as well as the depth of penetration of the dye into various zones of the root dentin. When working with the XP-endo system, the mean value of the area of stained dentin in the apical third was 11.56 ± 3.15, in the middle – 37.65 ± 9.3, in the coronal – 45.3 ± 12.3. In the Gentlefile group, the painted area of root dentin in the apical third was on apical 3.5 ± 1.39, in the middle- 8.5 ± 2.42, in the coronal – 12.8 ± 1.65. Differences are significant (p ≤ 0.05). SEM photographs of samples of the treated Gentlefile showed coarser dentinal surfaces, the presence of a smeared layer, fewer open dentinal tubules than by XP-endo.
Results of the study showed that the endodontic system XP-endo better treats the surface of the dentin root canals with the C-shaped configuration, compared with the Gentlefile.
About the Authors
I. V. Firsova
Department of Conservative Dentistry Volgograd State Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
D.M.S., professor, Head of Department.
N. N. Trigolos
Department of Conservative Dentistry Volgograd State Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Ph.D., assistant professor.
Yu. A. Makedonova
Department of Conservative Dentistry Volgograd State Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation; Volgograd Medical Scientific Center
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Ph.D., assistant professor.
N. N. Yaroshenko
Department of Conservative Dentistry Volgograd State Medical University of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Postgraduate.
References
1. Schilder H. Cleaning and shaping the root canal. Text // Dent. Clin. North Am. 1974. №18. P. 269-296.
2. Фирсова И. В., Триголос Н. Н., Македонова Ю. А., Ярошенко Н. Н. Сочетание С-образных корневых каналов в нижнечелюст¬ных премолярах и вторых нижнечелюстных молярах между собой и со сложными каналами других зубов нижней челюсти по дан¬ным конусно-лучевой компьютерной томографии // Эндодонтия Today. 2017. №1. С. 20-23. [Firsova I. V., Trigolos N. N., Makedonova Yu. A., Yaroshenko N. N. Sochetaniye S-obraznykh kornevykh kanalov v nizhnechelyustnykh premolyarakh i vtorykh nizhnechelyustnykh molyarakh mezhdu soboy i so slozhnymi kanalami drugikh zubov nizhney chelyusti po dannym konusno-luchevoy komp'yuternoy tomografii // Endodontiya today. 2017. №1. S. 20-23.]
3. Триголос Н. Н., Фирсова И. В., Македонова Ю. А. и др. Клини¬ческая анатомия моляров нижней челюсти по данным конусно-лу¬чевой компьютерной томографии // Эндодонтия today. 2017. №2. С. 24-28. [Trigolos N. N., Firsova I. V., Makedonova Yu. A. i dr. Klinicheskaya anatomiya molyarov nizhney chelyusti po dannym konusno-luchevoy komp'yuternoy tomografii // Endodontiya today. 2017. №2. S. 24-28.]
4. Cleghorn B. M., Christie W. H., Dong C. C. The root and root canal morphology of the human mandibular first premolar: a literature review // J Endod. 2007. №33. Р. 509-516.
5. Hamid Jafarzadeh, You-Nong Wu. The C-shaped root canal configuration: a review // J Endod. 2007. №33. Р. 517-523.
6. Yin X., Shun-pan Cheung G., Zhang C. et al. Micro-computed tomographic comparison of nickel-titanium rotary versus traditional instruments in C-shaped root canal system // J Endod. 2010. №36. Р. 708-712.
7. Триголос Н. Н., Македонова Ю. А., Фирсова И. В., Рябко И. Е. Конусно-лучевая компьютерная томография в исследовании морфологии сложных для эндодонтического лечения зубов ниж¬ней челюсти // Эндодонтия today. 2016. №1. С. 3-7. [Trigolos N. N., Makedonova Yu. A., Firsova I. V., Ryabko I. E. Konusno-luchevaya komp'yuternaya tomografiya v issledovanii morfologii slozhnykh dlya endodonticheskogo lecheniya zubov nizhney chelyusti // Endodontiya today. 2016. №1. S. 3-7.]
8. Garip Y., Sazak H., Gunday M., Hatipoglu S. Evaluation of smear layer removal after use of a canal brush: An SEM study // Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2010. №110 (2). e62–66.
9. Vertucci F. J. Root canal morphology and its relationship to endodontic procedures // Endodontic Topics. 2005. №10. Р. 3-29.
10. Gu Y. C., Zhang Y. P., Liao Z. G., Fei X. D. A micro-computed tomographic analysis of wall thickness of C-shaped canals in mandibular first premolars // J Endod. 2013. №39. Р. 973-976.
11. Paque F., Balmer M., Attin T., Peters O.A. Preparation of oval-shaped root canals in mandibular molars using nickel-titanium rotary instruments: a micro-computed tomography study. // J Endod 2010. №36. Р. 703-707.
12. Versiani M. A., Carvalho K. K. T., Mazzi-Chaves J. F., Sousa- Neto M. D. Micro-computed tomographic evaluation of the shaping ability of XP-endo shaper, irace, and edgefile systems in long oval-shaped canals // J Endod. 2018. Mar. №44 (3). P. 489-495.
13. Успенская О. А., Казарина Л. Н., Герберт Й. Применение мно¬гофункционального эндодонтического аппарата в стоматологиче¬ской практике // Эндодонтия today. 2017. №1. С. 54-56. [Uspenskaya O. A., Kazarina L. N., Gerbert J. Primenenie mnogofunkcional`nogo endodonticheskogo apparata v stomatologicheskoj praktike // Endodontiya today. 2017. №1. S. 54-56.]
14. Митронин А. В., Рабинович И. М., Корнетова И. В. Анома¬лии размеров и формы зубов: инвагинация зубов. Диагности¬ка и лечение // Эндодонтия today. 2016. №1. С. 39-41. [Mitronin A. V., Rabinovich I. M., Kornetova I. V. Anomalii razmerov i formy zubov: invaginaciya zubov. Diagnostika i lechenie // Endodontiya today. 2016. №1. S. 39-41.]
15. Митронин А. В., Собкина Н. А., Помещикова Н. И., Дмитри¬ева Л. А. Использование компьютерной микротомографии для оценки качества эндодонтической обработки зуба при использо¬вании современных инструментов // Эндодонтия today. 2018. №1. С. 22-26. [Mitronin A. V., Sobkina N. A., Pomeshhikova N. I., Dmitrieva L. A. Ispolzovanie kompyuternoj mikrotomografii dlya ocenki kachestva endodonticheskoj obrabotki zuba pri ispolzovanii sovremennyh instrumentov // Endodontiya today. 2018. №1. S. 22-26.]
Review
For citations:
Firsova I.V., Trigolos N.N., Makedonova Yu.A., Yaroshenko N.N. Comparative characteristic of the effectiveness of instrumental treatment of teeth with a C-shaped root canal. Endodontics Today. 2019;17(1):27-31. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.33925/1683-2981-2019-17-1-27-31
